Weekly Pitcher Rankings: A September to Remember?

Weekly Pitcher Rankings: A September to Remember?

This article is part of our Weekly Pitcher Rankings series.

Things are shaping up for an exciting month. It sure appears the NL West and the wild cards in both leagues will go down to the wire. Both Cy Young awards are up in the air. Even if he doesn't have ample innings to qualify for the AL Cy, we should have a few more chances to marvel at Shohei Ohtani's mound exploits while he chases 50 homers.

From a fantasy perspective, the first full week in September is busy with 96 games, including a doubleheader on Saturday between the Blue Jays and Orioles in Baltimore.

Here is your weekly reminder that I pull the starters from our Projected Starters page so any scheduling questions should be posted over there. I'm happy to address ranking questions below.

Please check back on Sunday night for the weekly refresh.

UPDATED: Monday September 6 12:45 AM ET

Week of Sept. 6-12

Mixed

RankPitcherTMOPPComments
1Zack WheelerPHI@MIL, COL 
2Gerrit ColeNYYTOR, @NYM3-0 with .47 ERA and .95 WHIP, fanning 30 over last 19 IP
3Max ScherzerLAD@STL, SD 
4Chris SaleBOSTB, @CWS 
5Brandon WoodruffMILPHI, @CLE 
6Max FriedATLWAS, MIASoft matchups at home
7Lance McCullers Jr.HOUSEA, LAA 
8Sonny GrayCIN@CHC, @STL3-0 with 2.79 ERA and .96 WHIP over last 7 GS with 38 K in 38.2 IP
9Aaron NolaPHI@MIL, COLSkills

Things are shaping up for an exciting month. It sure appears the NL West and the wild cards in both leagues will go down to the wire. Both Cy Young awards are up in the air. Even if he doesn't have ample innings to qualify for the AL Cy, we should have a few more chances to marvel at Shohei Ohtani's mound exploits while he chases 50 homers.

From a fantasy perspective, the first full week in September is busy with 96 games, including a doubleheader on Saturday between the Blue Jays and Orioles in Baltimore.

Here is your weekly reminder that I pull the starters from our Projected Starters page so any scheduling questions should be posted over there. I'm happy to address ranking questions below.

Please check back on Sunday night for the weekly refresh.

UPDATED: Monday September 6 12:45 AM ET

Week of Sept. 6-12

Mixed

RankPitcherTMOPPComments
1Zack WheelerPHI@MIL, COL 
2Gerrit ColeNYYTOR, @NYM3-0 with .47 ERA and .95 WHIP, fanning 30 over last 19 IP
3Max ScherzerLAD@STL, SD 
4Chris SaleBOSTB, @CWS 
5Brandon WoodruffMILPHI, @CLE 
6Max FriedATLWAS, MIASoft matchups at home
7Lance McCullers Jr.HOUSEA, LAA 
8Sonny GrayCIN@CHC, @STL3-0 with 2.79 ERA and .96 WHIP over last 7 GS with 38 K in 38.2 IP
9Aaron NolaPHI@MIL, COLSkills still solid but has incurred a few hiccups
10Walker BuehlerLADSD 
11Blake SnellSDLAA, @LAD1.83 ERA and .46 WHIP with 29 K over prior 19.2 IP
12Hyun Jin RyuTOR@NYY, @BAL 
13Framber ValdezHOULAA 
14Robbie RayTOR@BALNot slowing down: 1.64 ERA and .73 WHIP with 35 K over previous 22 IP
15Kevin GausmanSF@COL, @CHCCoors Field an issue but still deserves top-20 status
16Charlie MortonATLMIA 
17Joe MusgroveSD@LAD 
18Zac GallenARITEX 
19Sandy AlcantaraMIANYM 
20Triston McKenzieCLEMINMay seem aggressive, but pitching deep with high K
21Marcus StromanNYM@MIA 
22Adam WainwrightSTLLAD 
23Frankie MontasOAKCWS 
24Edward CabreraMIANYM, @ATLPedigree says the whiffs are coming
25Luis GarciaHOULAA 
26Carlos CarrascoNYM@MIA, NYY 
27Madison BumgarnerARI@SEA 
28Lucas GiolitoCWSBOS 
29Lance LynnCWSBOS 
30Corbin BurnesMIL@CLE 
31Tyler MahleCIN@STL 
32Jameson TaillonNYYTOR, @NYM 
33Taijuan WalkerNYMNYY 
34Julio UriasLAD@STL 
35Carlos HernandezKC@BAL 
36Luke WeaverARITEX 
37Aaron CivaleCLEMIN, MILSlated to return, should be able to throw around 75 pitches
38James KaprielianOAKCWS, TEXIn a rut but should rebound
39Luis CastilloCIN@STL 
40Yu DarvishSDLAA 
41Shohei OhtaniLAA@SD 
42Jose UrquidyHOUSEA 
43Nathan EovaldiBOSTB 
44Cal QuantrillCLEMIN 
45Rich HillNYM@MIA 
46Miles MikolasSTLLAD, CIN 
47Logan WebbSF@COL, @CHC 
48Marco GonzalesSEAARI 
49Corey KluberNYY@NYM 
50Alek ManoahTOR@NYY 
51Yusei KikuchiSEA@HOU, ARI 
52Eduardo RodriguezBOSTB, @CWS 
53Freddy PeraltaMILPHI 
54Jose BerriosTOR@NYY 
55John MeansBALKC 
56Ian AndersonATLMIA 
57Huascar YnoaATLWAS 
58Jordan MontgomeryNYYTOR 
59Kyle GibsonPHI@MIL 
60Bailey OberMIN@CLE, KC2.81 ERA and 1.08 WHIP since the break with 40 K in 41.2 IP
61Jake OdorizziHOUSEA 
62Reynaldo LopezCWS@OAK 
63Chris FlexenSEAARI 
64Tyler GilbertARI@SEA 
65Dylan CeaseCWSBOS 
66A.J. AlexyTEX@LAA 
67Sean ManaeaOAKCWS 
68Zac LowtherBALKC, TOR 
69Zach PlesacCLEMIL 
70Kwang Hyun KimSTLLAD 
71Wade MileyCIN@CHC 
72Touki ToussaintATLWAS 
73Paul BlackburnOAKTEX 
74Ranger SuarezPHICOL 
75Tarik SkubalDET@PIT 
76Bryse WilsonPITDET, WAS 
77David PriceLAD@STL 
78Michael PinedaMINKC 
79Chris PaddackSD@LAD 
80Casey MizeDETTB 
81German MarquezCOL@PHI 
82Nestor CortesNYYTOR 
83Mix 12 Reliever   
84Eric LauerMILPHI 
85Adrian HouserMIL@CLE 
86Taylor HearnTEX@OAK 
87Tanner HouckBOS@CWS 
88Trevor RogersMIA@ATL 
89Tylor MegillNYMNYY 
90Steven MatzTOR@NYY, @BAL 
91Kolby AllardTEX@OAK 
92Humberto CastellanosARI@SEA 
93Mix 15 Reliever   
94Cole IrvinOAKTEX 
95Jon GrayCOL@PHI 
96Mike MinorKC@BAL 
97Logan GilbertSEA@HOU 
98Tyler AndersonSEA@HOU 
99Dane DunningTEX@OAK 
100Elieser HernandezMIA@ATL 
101Jesus LuzardoMIANYM 
102Joe RyanMIN@CLE 
103Chris ArcherTB@DET 
104Mitch WhiteLAD@STL, SD 
105Justin SteeleCHCCIN, SF 
106Alec MillsCHCCIN 
107Kyle HendricksCHCSF 
108Randy DobnakMIN@CLE 
109Ryan YarbroughTB@BOS 
110John GantMIN@CLE 
111Vladimir GutierrezCIN@CHC 
112Shane McClanahanTB@BOS 
113Patrick CorbinWASNYM, @PIT 
114Logan AllenCLEMIN 
115Glenn OttoTEX@ARI 
116Josiah GrayWAS@PIT 
117Matthew BoydDETTB 
118Kris BubicKC@BAL, @MIN 
119Kyle FreelandCOLSF, @PHI 
120J.A. HappSTLLAD, CIN 
121Eli MorganCLEMIL 
122Mitch KellerPITDET 
123Jon LesterSTLCIN 
124Dallas KeuchelCWS@OAK 
125Jose SuarezLAA@HOU 
126Tyler AlexanderDETTB 
127Brady SingerKC@MIN 
128Drew RasmussenTB@BOS 
129Paolo EspinoWAS@ATL, @PIT 
130Matt ManningDET@PIT 
131Bailey FalterPHICOL 
132Jose QuintanaSF@CHC 
133Luis PatinoTB@DET 
134Wily PeraltaDET@PIT 
135Erick FeddeWAS@ATL 
136Steven BraultPITWAS 
137Trevor WilliamsNYM@WAS 
138Griffin JaxMINKC 
139Jaime BarriaLAATEX, @HOU 
140Zach DaviesCHCSF 
141Michael WachaTB@DET 
142Jackson KowarKC@BAL 
143Dillon PetersPITDET 
144Ryan FeltnerCOL@PHI 
145Anthony DeSclafaniSF@COL 
146Keegan AkinBALTOR 
147Jordan LylesTEX@ARI 
148Daniel LynchKC@MIN 
149Thomas HatchTOR@BAL 
150Adrian SampsonCHCCIN 
151Packy NaughtonLAA@SD, @HOU 
152Wil CrowePITWAS 
153Antonio SenzatelaCOLSF 
154Matt HarveyBALKC, TOR 
155Jimmy LambertCWS@OAK 
156Chris EllisBALKC 
157Spenser WatkinsBALTOR 
158Sean NolinWAS@ATL 
159Chi Chi GonzalezCOLSF 

American League

RankPitcherTMOPPComment
1Gerrit ColeNYYTOR, @NYM3-0 with .47 ERA and .95 WHIP, fanning 30 over last 19 IP
2Chris SaleBOSTB, @CWS 
3Lance McCullers Jr.HOUSEA, LAA 
4Hyun Jin RyuTOR@NYY, @BAL 
5Framber ValdezHOULAA 
6Robbie RayTOR@BALNot slowing down: 1.64 ERA and .73 WHIP with 35 K over previous 22 IP
7Triston McKenzieCLEMINMay seem aggressive, but pitching deep with high K
8Frankie MontasOAKCWS 
9Luis GarciaHOULAA 
10Lucas GiolitoCWSBOS 
11Lance LynnCWSBOS 
12Jameson TaillonNYYTOR, @NYM 
13Carlos HernandezKC@BAL 
14Aaron CivaleCLEMIN, MILSlated to return, should be able to throw around 75 pitches
15James KaprielianOAKCWS, TEXIn a rut but should rebound
16Shohei OhtaniLAA@SD 
17Jose UrquidyHOUSEA 
18Nathan EovaldiBOSTB 
19Cal QuantrillCLEMIN 
20Marco GonzalesSEAARI 
21Corey KluberNYY@NYM 
22Alek ManoahTOR@NYY 
23Yusei KikuchiSEA@HOU, ARI 
24Eduardo RodriguezBOSTB, @CWS 
25Jose BerriosTOR@NYY 
26John MeansBALKC 
27Jordan MontgomeryNYYTOR 
28Bailey OberMIN@CLE, KC2.81 ERA and 1.08 WHIP since the break with 40 K in 41.2 IP
29Jake OdorizziHOUSEA 
30Reynaldo LopezCWS@OAK 
31Chris FlexenSEAARI 
32Dylan CeaseCWSBOS 
33A.J. AlexyTEX@LAA 
34Sean ManaeaOAKCWS 
35Zac LowtherBALKC, TOR 
36Zach PlesacCLEMIL 
37Paul BlackburnOAKTEX 
38Tarik SkubalDET@PIT 
39Michael PinedaMINKC 
40Casey MizeDETTB 
41Nestor CortesNYYTOR 
42Taylor HearnTEX@OAK 
43Tanner HouckBOS@CWS 
44Steven MatzTOR@NYY, @BAL 
45Kolby AllardTEX@OAK 
46Cole IrvinOAKTEX 
47Mike MinorKC@BAL 
48Logan GilbertSEA@HOU 
49Tyler AndersonSEA@HOU 
50Dane DunningTEX@OAK 
51Joe RyanMIN@CLE 
52Chris ArcherTB@DET 
53AL Reliever   
54Randy DobnakMIN@CLE 
55Ryan YarbroughTB@BOS 
56John GantMIN@CLE 
57Shane McClanahanTB@BOS 
58Logan AllenCLEMIN 
59Glenn OttoTEX@ARI 
60Matthew BoydDETTB 
61Kris BubicKC@BAL, @MIN 
62Eli MorganCLEMIL 
63Dallas KeuchelCWS@OAK 
64Jose SuarezLAA@HOU 
65Tyler AlexanderDETTB 
66Brady SingerKC@MIN 
67Drew RasmussenTB@BOS 
68Matt ManningDET@PIT 
69Luis PatinoTB@DET 
70Wily PeraltaDET@PIT 
71Griffin JaxMINKC 
72Jaime BarriaLAATEX, @HOU 
73Michael WachaTB@DET 
74Jackson KowarKC@BAL 
75Keegan AkinBALTOR 
76Jordan LylesTEX@ARI 
77Daniel LynchKC@MIN 
78Thomas HatchTOR@BAL 
79Packy NaughtonLAA@SD, @HOU 
80Matt HarveyBALKC, TOR 
81Jimmy LambertCWS@OAK 
82Chris EllisBALKC 
83Spenser WatkinsBALTOR 

National League

RankPitcherTMOPPComment
1Zack WheelerPHI@MIL, COL 
2Max ScherzerLAD@STL, SD 
3Brandon WoodruffMILPHI, @CLE 
4Max FriedATLWAS, MIASoft matchups at home
5Sonny GrayCIN@CHC, @STL3-0 with 2.79 ERA and .96 WHIP over last 7 GS with 38 K in 38.2 IP
6Aaron NolaPHI@MIL, COLSkills still solid but has incurred a few hiccups
7Walker BuehlerLADSD 
8Blake SnellSDLAA, @LAD1.83 ERA and .46 WHIP with 29 K over prior 19.2 IP
9Kevin GausmanSF@COL, @CHCCoors Field an issue but still deserves top-20 status
10Charlie MortonATLMIA 
11Joe MusgroveSD@LAD 
12Zac GallenARITEX 
13Sandy AlcantaraMIANYM 
14Marcus StromanNYM@MIA 
15Adam WainwrightSTLLAD 
16Edward CabreraMIANYM, @ATLPedigree says the whiffs are coming
17Carlos CarrascoNYM@MIA, NYY 
18Madison BumgarnerARI@SEA 
19Corbin BurnesMIL@CLE 
20Tyler MahleCIN@STL 
21Taijuan WalkerNYMNYY 
22Julio UriasLAD@STL 
23Luke WeaverARITEX 
24Luis CastilloCIN@STL 
25Yu DarvishSDLAA 
26Rich HillNYM@MIA 
27Miles MikolasSTLLAD, CIN 
28Logan WebbSF@COL, @CHC 
29Freddy PeraltaMILPHI 
30Ian AndersonATLMIA 
31Huascar YnoaATLWAS 
32Kyle GibsonPHI@MIL 
33Tyler GilbertARI@SEA 
34Kwang Hyun KimSTLLAD 
35Wade MileyCIN@CHC 
36Touki ToussaintATLWAS 
37Ranger SuarezPHICOL 
38Bryse WilsonPITDET, WAS 
39David PriceLAD@STL 
40Chris PaddackSD@LAD 
41German MarquezCOL@PHI 
42Eric LauerMILPHI 
43Adrian HouserMIL@CLE 
44Trevor RogersMIA@ATL 
45Tylor MegillNYMNYY 
46Humberto CastellanosARI@SEA 
47Jon GrayCOL@PHI 
48Elieser HernandezMIA@ATL 
49Jesus LuzardoMIANYM 
50Mitch WhiteLAD@STL, SD 
51Justin SteeleCHCCIN, SF 
52NL Reliever   
53Alec MillsCHCCIN 
54Kyle HendricksCHCSF 
55Vladimir GutierrezCIN@CHC 
56Patrick CorbinWASNYM, @PIT 
57Josiah GrayWAS@PIT 
58Kyle FreelandCOLSF, @PHI 
59J.A. HappSTLLAD, CIN 
60Mitch KellerPITDET 
61Jon LesterSTLCIN 
62Paolo EspinoWAS@ATL, @PIT 
63Bailey FalterPHICOL 
64Jose QuintanaSF@CHC 
65Erick FeddeWAS@ATL 
66Steven BraultPITWAS 
67Trevor WilliamsNYM@WAS 
68Zach DaviesCHCSF 
69Dillon PetersPITDET 
70Ryan FeltnerCOL@PHI 
71Anthony DeSclafaniSF@COL 
72Adrian SampsonCHCCIN 
73Wil CrowePITWAS 
74Antonio SenzatelaCOLSF 
75Sean NolinWAS@ATL 
76Chi Chi GonzalezCOLSF 

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only MLB Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire MLB fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Todd Zola
Todd has been writing about fantasy baseball since 1997. He won NL Tout Wars and Mixed LABR in 2016 as well as a multi-time league winner in the National Fantasy Baseball Championship. Todd is now setting his sights even higher: The Rotowire Staff League. Lord Zola, as he's known in the industry, won the 2013 FSWA Fantasy Baseball Article of the Year award and was named the 2017 FSWA Fantasy Baseball Writer of the Year. Todd is a five-time FSWA awards finalist.
Giants-Diamondbacks & MLB Bets & Expert Picks for Thursday, April 18
Giants-Diamondbacks & MLB Bets & Expert Picks for Thursday, April 18
MLB FAAB Factor: Ryan O'Hearn Is Red Hot
MLB FAAB Factor: Ryan O'Hearn Is Red Hot
Marlins-Cubs & Giants-Diamondbacks, MLB Bets & Expert Picks for Thursday, April 18
Marlins-Cubs & Giants-Diamondbacks, MLB Bets & Expert Picks for Thursday, April 18
MLB DFS: DraftKings Plays and Strategy for Thursday, April 18
MLB DFS: DraftKings Plays and Strategy for Thursday, April 18